HomeCarbon CreditsLand Dispute Casts Doubt on Carbon Credits from Brazil's Amazon

Land Dispute Casts Doubt on Carbon Credits from Brazil’s Amazon

The Jari Pará REDD+ Project, a corporate conservation initiative in Brazil’s Amazon rainforest, has come under scrutiny for selling carbon credits from publicly-owned land without state authorization. 

The project covers around 497,000 hectares, which Verra approved to issue carbon credits. Verra is a leading organization that certifies offsets.

However, a Thomson Reuters Foundation’s company (Context News)  investigation found that the project operated on disputed land ownership. This spurs a legal battle and raises concerns about the credibility of offsets from areas with contested land ownership.

The Disputed Jari Pará Project’s Land Ownership

Most of the forestry project area is registered as public land. Yet, the Jari Pará REDD+ project continued to operate on disputed land ownership, according to a Context investigation. 

The project began in 2014 with the aim to reduce emissions from deforestation and forest degradation while protecting biodiversity. But a 2012 state court ruling found that the company claiming to own the land, Jari Celulose, did not have the right to do so. This resulted in the cancellation of the land title in 2016.

  • In 2018, the state registered Fazenda Saracura, a 386,000-hectare land parcel, as public property, renaming it Gleba Arraiolos. 

Despite this, the 2019 Jari Pará REDD+ Project description and validation documents listed on Verra’s website link to the land parcel registered under Jari Celulose in Brazil’s Land Management System (SIGEF). It states that the land title was canceled in 2016 and is invalid. 

In particular, here is the project’s land parcels according to Context.

Jari Para project in Brazil Amazon
Map: Diana Baptista, André Cabette Fábio Source: Verra’s project 1811 registry, Report “Action against land-grabbing in register offices in the state of Pará”, Pará State Prosecution, Brazilian System of Land Management (SIGEF), Monte Alegre Real Estate Register Office

Brazilian law requires private businesses to have state permission to operate in public forests. But Jari Celulose claimed to be the “legitimate owner” of the estate in registration documents submitted to Verra in 2019.

Impact on the Credibility of Carbon Credits from Brazil’s Amazon

The REDD+ project’s sale of carbon credits based on invalid land ownership has raised doubts about the offsets’ credibility. Verra launched a review of the project and suspended the issuance of new carbon credits in response to the investigation. 

International firms and domestic companies bought credits from the Jari Pará project to offset their climate-heating emissions while protecting forests. Big names include Janssen, 3M, CNN, and BWM, as well as Globo and Bradesco.

State officials and researchers argue that the registration of Fazenda Saracura as public property questions the REDD+ project’s credibility. The cancellations and blockages against Jari Celulose’s land claims ensure that carbon credits from Brazil’s Amazon cannot be traded, according to Herena Melo, the agrarian prosecutor who led the investigation. 

While Jari Celulose claims to have the right to operate a carbon project on the land due to a 2021 Pará state lower court ruling, the case remains undecided.

The Brazil project’s sale of carbon credits from disputed land ownership highlights the unresolved issue of land-grabbing in the Amazon, with carbon credits making the situation more complex. 

Verra has launched a review of the project. Still, state officials and researchers argue that land-grabbing remains a significant problem in the region. 

The credibility of carbon credits from the Jari Pará REDD+ project in Brazil’s Amazon has come into question. This ultimately casts doubts about the validity of carbon offsets from areas with contested land ownership.

Most Popular
LATEST CARBON NEWS

Japan Steps Up as Carbon Credit Leader with $70 Billion Push for Net Zero

Japan is starting to lead in carbon credit markets as global demand for sustainable solutions grows. With significant investments, bilateral agreements, and innovative approaches,...

The Curious Case of Top CEOs’ Private Jet Emissions

Are those billionaires flying in the sky giving a stark reminder of climate inequality? Certainly yes. It showcases the disproportionate environmental impact of the...

BeZero Carbon Secures $32 Million to Boost Carbon Market Integrity

BeZero Carbon, a global leader in carbon ratings, has successfully raised $32 million in a Series C funding round. The funding will help enhance...

TikTok’s 50-Million-Ton Carbon Crisis: Almost 7x Bigger Than Meta’s Footprint

TikTok, owned by ByteDance, has rapidly become one of the most popular social media platforms globally. The platform has reshaped how people engage with...
CARBON INVESTOR EDUCATION

Top 5 Carbon ETFs for Sustainable Investing in 2025

Like stocks, investors can buy and sell Exchange-Traded Funds (ETFs) whenever the market is open. Often investing in carbon credits through ETFs offers a...

Green AI Explained: Fueling Innovation with a Smaller Carbon Footprint

As artificial intelligence (AI) continues to transform industries and unlock new opportunities, its environmental impact is also a matter of concern. While AI holds...

What’s Shaping North America’s Natural Gas in 2024? Insights from Wood Mackenzie

The natural gas market has immensely benefitted this year from robust storage levels and stabilized prices after the sharp spikes of 2022. However, challenges...

EU’s Green Bonds to Slash 55 MTS of CO₂ Annually. Can it Hit Europe’s 2050 Net Zero Target?

The European Commission released its NextGenerationEU (NGEU) Green Bonds Allocation and Impact Report 2024 explaining how proceeds from green bonds are being used to...