HomeCarbon MarketsIs Canada's Forest Carbon Emissions Accounting Misleading

Is Canada’s Forest Carbon Emissions Accounting Misleading

The forest carbon accounting of Canada is underestimated and misleading, according to a report from the Natural Resources Defense Council.

The Canadian federal government has been reporting direct emissions for almost all sectors of the economy.

But the forestry sector’s emission is reported differently using the concept of “combined net flux” which include emissions from natural processes and industrial activities.

The government accounting for the forestry sector’s emissions show that logging emissions are almost balanced by removals of forest regrowth.

But according to the report, such calculations are misleading and damaging.

The government doesn’t account for the carbon released by wildfires. But it factors in carbon captured by forest regrowth even if there’s no logging in the area and there’s no human activities at play.

Michael Polanyi of Nature Canada who co-sponsored the report commented:

“Canada is taking credit for carbon removal from vast forests that have never been logged as a way of masking emissions.”

He further said that the difference in calculation matters because the country can’t meet its climate goals if it doesn’t have a clear picture of the baseline.

Natural Resources Canada, the report’s sponsor, said its method follows the United Nations guidelines many countries use.

The report explains and shows Canada’s high-emissions logging sector, how it compares to other sectors, and what the government should do to fix the gaps in forest carbon credit accounting.

Logging Emissions in Canada

Carbon credits produced by forest carbon projects are among the most popular and pricey. That’s because they protect trees that store huge amounts of carbon.

But each year, loggers clearcut over 550,000 hectares of forest across Canada, mostly in primary forest areas.

The report states that the government does not report detailed emissions from the sector. And it doesn’t have a clear strategy on how to reduce the GHG emitted by logging (unlike it does for other high-emitting industries).

Doing so compromises Canada’s climate ambition – cut emissions to 45% below 2005 levels by 2030. And that depends on accurate carbon accounting of emissions from all major sectors, according to the report.

Thus, the authors used a different method of calculating the logging industry’s emissions using the government’s data.

  • They show in the chart below that the sector emitted 75 Mt CO2e. That is equal to over 10% of Canada’s total GHG emissions.

Annual Net Logging Emissions

canada net logging emission

The left column shows emissions and removals associated with logging (emissions are positive, and removals are negative). The right column depicts the net (sum of) emissions and removals.

The analysis takes into account three components to represent net emissions from logging. These are:

  1. Total amount of forest carbon that is taken out of the forest upon logging
  2. Net carbon released to the atmosphere – subtracted – as it’s stored in long-lived wood products
  3. Forest carbon removals – subtracted – due to regrowth after logging

Logging is a large net source of Canada’s emissions

The figure is a conservative estimate but places the logging sector’s emissions on par with oil sands production and higher than the electricity sector’s emissions.

The chart depicts emissions from logging relative to the other two heavy-emitting sectors.

net logging emissions vs. other sectors

Net logging emissions in the country were higher than emissions from oil sands operations every year from 2005 to 2018.

net logging emissions annual

The average net emissions of logging each year were 82 Mt CO2e from 2015 – 2020. While oil sands production has an average of 78 Mt CO2e over that period.

Remarkably, Canada has pledged to phase out coal and cut emissions from oil and gas by at least 75% from 2012 levels by 2030.

But under Prime Minister Trudeau’s climate-oriented government, emissions from oil and gas have expanded. And as seen in the table above, oil sands emissions are consistently increasing.

Hence, correct carbon accounting of emissions from all sectors, including forestry, is even more vital to help Canada achieve its climate commitments.

One of the authors noted that people generally accept that accurate reporting of emissions is critical, and their findings can help defend the argument that emissions from logging should be regulated like how it is in other industries.

The report provides 4 policy recommendations for Canada to consider in its forest carbon accounting.

Policy Recommendations for Forest Carbon Accounting

  1. Transparent reporting of the logging industry’s net annual emissions as it does for other high-emitting sectors
  2. Create a strategy to reduce the sector’s emissions that’s in line with Canada’s wider emissions reduction plans and commitments
  3. Reduce emissions from logging by directly regulating the forestry industry
  4. Address biases and other gaps in forest carbon accounting

Acknowledging and regulating logging emissions will lead to Canada’s new emissions reduction pathways. It will also help build in the proper incentives for mitigating climate impacts as the report concluded.

Most Popular

The Core Carbon Principles

The Integrity Council for the Voluntary Carbon Market has released their long-awaited Core Carbon Principles (CCPs), which could lead toward additional labels that will...

Canadian Gov’t Sets out $83B for Clean Investment Tax Credits

Canadian industries seeking to slash their carbon footprint can expect $83 billion in clean investment tax credits after the federal government of Canada unveiled...

EU to Auction €8 Billion Carbon Credits Earlier this 2023

The European Union (EU) seeks to carry out early auctions of its carbon credits or allowances this year, starting from July. The goal of this...

Land Dispute Casts Doubt on Carbon Credits from Brazil’s Amazon

The Jari Pará REDD+ Project, a corporate conservation initiative in Brazil's Amazon rainforest, has come under scrutiny for selling carbon credits from publicly-owned land...

The Core Carbon Principles

The Integrity Council for the Voluntary Carbon Market has released their long-awaited Core Carbon Principles (CCPs), which could lead toward additional labels that will...

What are Blue Carbon Credits? Everything You Need to Know

Carbon credits from offset projects such as reforestation and direct air capture have become popular, but a new crediting method still in its infancy...

What are Renewable Energy Credits vs. Carbon Credits

Also known as green tag, the use of renewable energy credits (RECs) have been on the rise as entities are looking for ways to...

Wood Vault: a Carbon Storage System to lock CO2 away

Removing carbon dioxide through dead trees and storing it for thousands of years underground is a mission that seems to attract nobody. But a...