HomeCarbon CreditsICVCM's New Framework: Raising the Bar for Carbon Credits

ICVCM’s New Framework: Raising the Bar for Carbon Credits

The Integrity Council for Voluntary Carbon Market (ICVCM) released the long-awaited framework that provides guidance on defining what makes carbon credits of high quality, which can help boost the credibility of the voluntary carbon market (VCM)

ICVCM’s Assessment Framework is part of their Core Carbon Principles (CCPs) published last March. The framework will be used to assess if carbon credits adhere to its high-integrity CCPs. The CCPs include 10 codes categorized into three areas: governance; emissions impact and sustainable development.

CCP-labeled credits will be available to buyers by the end of the year. 

The Integrity Council believes that with their new framework, the VCMs now have a global standard for quality by addressing market issues on confidence and integrity. Executives of the ICVCM highlight the importance of high-quality credits in reducing emissions and delivering global climate goals.  

ICVCM assessment framework commentsCarbon Prices Recovering From A Dip

The release of the guidance comes at a critical time for the $2 billion carbon market. The growing criticism over some carbon offset projects caused a sharp decline in market liquidity and carbon prices. 

Nature-based carbon credit prices (NGEO), in particular, are largely impacted.

Nature Based Carbon

But with various initiatives introduced, carbon credit prices started to recover slowly. As per S&P Global Commodity Insights’ Platts assessment, nature-based credit prices (Platts CNC) recovered from a record low of $1/mtCO2e in May to $2.45/mtCO2e in July. S&P Global data suggested that prices for the same credit reached an average of $9.55/mtCO2e last year. 

carbon credit prices S&P global Platts CNCMany industry experts hope that this development will inspire more carbon removal and reduction efforts by bringing certainty to VCMs. But for a carbon credit to earn a CCP label, it has to go through two assessment levels. 

  • Program Level

This assessment framework and procedure were first released alongside the CCP guidelines. A dedicated “Assessment Platform” is part of this second release specifically designed for crediting programs applying for CCP eligibility. 

The ICVCM refers to these programs as a “standard setting program that registers mitigation activities and issues carbon credits”. Established programs are the Gold Standard, American Carbon Registry, and Verra’s Verified Carbon Standard (VCS).

  • Carbon Credit Category Level

This is the newly released assessment guidance but the framework doesn’t define yet what a ‘Category’ means. The Integrity Council will form a Categories Working Group (CWG) tasked to finalize the definition based on data gathered from rating agencies and publicly available information.  

The CWG will recommend which categories must be prioritized for approval, which ones need further assessment, and which carbon credits don’t deserve the CCP label. 

According to the framework, carbon credits must support carbon projects that align with net zero, additionality, permanent, and robustly quantified

The goal of the framework is to ensure that the highest quality carbon credits prevail and get premium prices. The assessment process is shown below.

ICVCM assessment processSome carbon crediting programs and standards are revisiting and making some changes in their methodologies.

For instance, the world’s leading carbon registry, VCS, has been improving the quality of its forest carbon credits. The mostly used crediting program will finalize its REDD+ methodology by the last quarter of this year. 

Quality Issues Remain, Framework to Strengthen

While some improvements are happening in the market, some experts still warn that quality issues of projects continue to persist. 

Others say that these efforts from ICVCM and similar initiatives aren’t a “silver bullet” that can instantly resolve the issue of quality. Some say that the growing scrutiny of the VCM highlighted significant failures of the market to deliver at a project level. This has clearly impacted the supply of carbon credits as reported by S&P Global for different projects. 

supply of carbon credits S&P
Chart from S&P Global Commodity Insights

Still, as major initiatives focus on the quality of the credits circulating in the market, improvements will happen soon. The Integrity Council will start forming various multi-stakeholder working groups to make things clear and strengthen the framework.

The carbon market governance body will also keep on updating its guidelines and frameworks over time. That means incorporating new developments, technological advances, and lessons learned into the updated version of the framework. 

The release of this initiative comes after the VCMI launched its Claims Code of Practice just recently. It’s a separate guideline seeking to make the demand side of the VCM more credible. The Code will help guide companies in using carbon credits to voluntarily offset their emissions.

Both VCMI and ICVCM aim for the same thing: to bring integrity to the VCM. They’re also currently working to create an integrated market integrity framework aimed at improving carbon offset quality. 

The ICVCM will start announcing CCP-Eligible programs and CCP-Approved categories later this 2023, making CCP-labeled credits available for buyers before the year ends.

Will this new threshold for quality bring prices of carbon credits up to premium? That’s something to watch out for in the market once the CCP-labeled credits are up and running. 

Most Popular
LATEST CARBON NEWS

2024 is The Golden Era For Europe’s Renewable Energy: Here’s Why

In 2024, Europe's market for renewable power purchase agreements (PPAs) is poised for substantial growth. Moreover, major mergers and acquisitions (M&A) also happened in...

Audi and Alfa Romeo Take The Ride to Electrification

Amid the rapid adoption of electrification, electric cars are reshaping the automotive industry, promising enhanced performance, efficiency, and a cleaner future. This momentum is...

Is the EV Market’s Momentum Slowing?

Bloomberg Outlook 2024 According to the Bloomberg EV Outlook Report, the global electric vehicle (EV) market in 2024 shows varied progress across different regions and...

Microsoft Strikes 2 Record-Breaking Carbon Credit Deals

Microsoft has entered into a groundbreaking agreement with BTG Pactual Timberland Investment Group (TIG), committing to provide 8 million carbon removal credits, marking the...
CARBON INVESTOR EDUCATION

What Is COP28? Key Issues to Watch Out at 2023 Climate Summit

After a record-breaking year of devastating effects of climate change, from record wildfires in Greece and Canada to floods in Libya, the United Nations...

Climate Disclosure: New Corporate Standards for a Net Zero World

As part of the world’s continued efforts to combat climate change and transition towards net zero, one important piece of the puzzle is new...

Carbon Pricing: Understanding The Economics and Trends of Fighting Climate Change

As global temperatures continue to rise, the urgency surrounding climate policies has intensified, thrusting carbon pricing into the limelight of climate discussions. The race to...

The EU Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD): Key Things to Know

Companies operating in the European Union will have to deal with new non-financial and sustainability reporting requirements starting January 2024 with the EU's Corporate...