HomeCarbon CreditsVerification Delays Can Cost Carbon Project Developers $2.6B

Verification Delays Can Cost Carbon Project Developers $2.6B

Project developers could lose $2.6 billion by 2030 while the voluntary carbon market (VCM) may also lose 4.8 GT of carbon credits due to verification delays, according to a report by Thallo.

Climate tech start-up Thallo uses blockchain technology to democratize the carbon markets, making it easier for buyers and sellers of carbon credits to find each other.

The company published a report that combines carbon project developer insights and identifies challenges to scaling the VCM.

Its report called “Fast Forward, Challenges to Scaling the Voluntary Carbon Market” identifies key bottlenecks including:

  • verification delays,
  • limited access to early-stage financing, and
  • inefficiencies in the value chain caused by intermediaries.

The report also presents solutions for scaling the VCM. And that particularly includes improved financing through forward models.

Here are the key findings from Thallo’s report:

The biggest bottlenecks involve the registries and validation & verification bodies (VVBs), as well as the GHG crediting programs.

Verification delays can cost VCM project developers as much as $2.6 billion. This will also cost the planet 4.8 gigatonnes of un-deployed carbon credits by 2030 as shown in the chart below.

  • That corresponds to not offsetting 37 million U.S. citizens by the end of the decade.

carbon credit issuance scenarios

Carbon crediting programs argue that there are too few VVBs vs. the number of projects.

One solution to this problem as stated in the report is to scale up crediting programs by adding a workforce to match the demand. This is what Verra and Gold Standard are doing.

They create a specific team to improve the technical capacities of VVBs and national accreditation entities by:

  • dedicated training,
  • tightening review of projects by pushing back earlier on poor quality projects, and
  • working more collaboratively with accreditation entities.

By resolving and cutting project verification delays in VCM, the speed of carbon credit issuance can double.

Financing is a barrier.

There are three categories of carbon project developers – big & experienced, intermediate, and small & new.

Small to midsize project developers face the greatest financing challenges. Meanwhile, the big and experienced ones like South Pole find fundraising, not a real challenge.

Among the five different financing methods, the most common ways are forward purchase agreements and own funding. But each method has its challenges and benefits as to how developers see it.

  • 90% of project developers agree that forward products will be key to scaling the VCM.

Intermediaries’ and investors’ profits account for ⅓ of VCM value in 2021.

With 500 million carbon credits traded in 2021, $650 million went to the pockets of investors and brokers – not project developers.

  • That accounts for one-third of the revenues the VCM generated in 2021.

In a best-case scenario, project developers sell directly to end buyers without the need for an intermediary. In this case, up to 60% of revenues goes back to the climate or local communities for long-lasting impact.

But under a worst-case scenario, brokers can take as much as 78% of the revenues of the carbon credit sales.

So, why do project developers still work with brokers? Some believe that they help connect with buyers and it’s convenient for price discovery.

On the other hand, a well-functioning carbon exchange offers good value to developers by:

  • Connecting buyers and sellers without taking large fees
  • Giving clear price signals, and
  • Providing transparency around the quality of credits

Forward Models to Scale VCM

Thallo’s report also explores forward models as one way that can help scale the VCM. In particular, it looks into forward financing used by registries like Verra and Gold Standard.

  • In VCM, forwards are more significant than futures to make project development go faster.

Since carbon projects are different, it’s hard to have standardized futures contracts. Futures contracts are traded on exchanges such as ICE and CBL. Most of them have vintages in the past.

On the contrary, a future contract is an arrangement that is made over-the-counter (OTC) and settles just once at the end of the contract.

Forward contracts can be closed earlier in the life cycle of a carbon project. This enables much-needed financial support to early-stage projects.

  • The volume of forward transactions rose by 65% from 2020 to 2021.

Web3 projects such as Ivy Protocol, Carb0n.fi, and Flowcarbon are developing standardized platforms for forward models.

For the small and midsize project developer, Thallo has the following proposal for a focused forward model:

forward model for VCM project developers

The Fast Forward VCM report includes inputs from over 30 players in the VCM.

Most Popular
LATEST CARBON NEWS

Saudi Power Firm Inks $7B Green Hydrogen Thailand Deal

Saudi Arabian renewables developer ACWA Power signed a $7 billion agreement with two Thai state-owned companies to develop green hydrogen in Thailand. ACWA Power is...

U.S. to Sanction Brazil’s Amazon Deforestation Criminals

In a bid to better address climate change, the United States aims to sanction environmental criminals who contributed to the worsening deforestation in Brazil's...

Seafields Unveils 1 Billion Carbon Removal Project Off West Africa

Seafields revealed its plan to tokenize one billion carbon removal credits from a seaweed farm off West Africa in partnership with the blockchain-based carbon...

Carbon Credits From Drip Irrigation

An Israeli company Netafim introduced its landmark carbon credits initiative for global rice farmers with its pioneering drip irrigation technology at the COP27 summit. Netafim...
CARBON INVESTOR EDUCATION

How Do I Buy Carbon Credits?

Companies and individuals alike have been investing in carbon credits to offset their carbon emissions. But not everyone is familiar with how to buy...

How to Calculate Carbon Credits? (5 Easy Steps to Follow)

Many companies and governments are finding it critical to know how to calculate carbon credits and price them. Carbon credits and offsets are vital...

What is Carbon Financing?

In the simplest sense, carbon financing is the process of putting money to entities or activities that most need them or can put them...

The Timeline of the COP Conferences Leading to COP27

Following the wake of the Montreal Protocol in 1987 the UN in conjunction with the World Meteorological Organization established the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate...