HomeCarbon CreditsCarbon Initiative Reveals New Online Scoring Tool for Carbon Credits

Carbon Initiative Reveals New Online Scoring Tool for Carbon Credits

The Carbon Credit Quality Initiative (CCQI) launched a new online scoring tool to assess the quality of three types of carbon credits.

The CCQI is led by Environmental Defense Fund, World Wildlife Fund (WWF-US), and Oeko-Institut. It offers free online resources that include its robust assessment method and interactive scoring tool.

The free online CCQI Scoring Tool allows buyers to evaluate the quality of carbon credits. This will help them to make more informed decisions in the booming carbon credit market when buying credits.

Ultimately, the initiative aims to improve the quality of carbon credits transacted in the market. It does so by showing which ones provide the greatest climate impact.

CCQI Online Scoring Tool for Carbon Credits Quality

Carbon credits are tradeable permits allowing polluters to offset carbon emissions or prevent them. Typically, one carbon credit equals one ton of carbon or other greenhouse gases.

The CCQI online tool gives scores for the quality of three commonly used projects that generate carbon credits. These are:

  1. landfill gas utilization, 
  2. establishment of natural forest, and 
  3. efficient cookstoves.

The first set of carbon credit quality assessments launched by the CCQI is under the four largest carbon crediting programs: 

  • the Clean Development Mechanism (CDM), 
  • Climate Action Reserve, 
  • Gold Standard and 
  • Verified Carbon Standard (Verra).

The need for quality improvement

The voluntary carbon market has grown so fast in recent years. More and more entities have set net zero emissions goals and use carbon credits to offset part of their emissions or to finance climate measures.

But the quality of carbon credits available varies to date. And the results of CCQI’s first round of scorings confirm this. It reveals that carbon credits perform great in some criteria but poorly in others.

For instance, efficient cookstove projects have drawbacks in quantifying emission reductions and addressing non-permanence. Yet, most often they generate high environmental and social benefits.

As per the Senior Director of Climate at Environmental Defense Fund Pedro Martins Barata:

“CCQI’s first round of scoring confirmed that there is both wheat and chaff in the carbon credit market. The important thing, however, is that the consumer can tell the difference.”

He added that CCQI’s free and transparent online scoring tool can move the market toward quality by helping users understand what quality means for carbon credits.

CCQI methodology’s quality criteria for carbon credits

Under the CCQI’s methodology, a carbon credit is scored on an interval scale of 1 through 5 against several quality objectives. This enables buyers to understand the nuances and trade-offs in the quality of carbon credits to make an informed decision.

Lambert Schneider from the Oeko-Institut remarked that:

“What makes a high-quality carbon credit is a complex question… We designed our Scoring Tool so that users could have a nuanced 360-degree view of different quality features of carbon credits. The scorings show a mixed performance of carbon credit programs.”

In particular, the CCQI scores show notable differences between carbon crediting programs.

For instance, the scoring results reveal that Clean Development Mechanism has the best third-party auditing rules. While the Climate Action Reserve performed best in its approach to compensating for potential non-permanence.

Likewise, the Gold Standard has the most comprehensive environmental and social safeguards. Whereas the Verified Carbon Standard or Verra performed high in its governance, transparency, and approaches for reducing non-permanence risks.

According to Brad Schallert, WWF’s director of carbon market governance and aviation:

“When buyers come to the carbon credit market, they are sometimes surprised that detailed guidance on how to evaluate credits is not publicly available… CCQI hopes to fill this information gap by offering our scoring tool.”

Using CCQI’s online tool is one of several steps a buyer can take when performing due diligence on how carbon credits differ in quality.

CCQI’s 7 Quality Objectives

What makes a high-quality carbon credit is not a simple question. It depends on many different factors.

The CCQI tool uses 19 quality criteria assessed based on their importance and the context in which the carbon credit is generated and used.

For example, some criteria may not be relevant for all types of climate mitigation activities. This is particularly the case with measures that address the risk of non-permanence.

These criteria are then organized under CCQI’s seven “Quality Objectives”. The table below identifies and explains each quality criterion.

CCQI carbon credits quality objectives

CCQI will expand its free online Scoring Tool to assess more carbon credits. This is to let users know how other project types and programs perform on quality as well as cover a bigger part of the market.

CCQI’s next round of scores will be up for release later by the end of this year.

Most Popular

How The First Carbon Negative Nation of Bhutan Did It

As the world’s richest and largest emitting countries are struggling to reduce emissions, Bhutan became the first carbon negative nation. Fog-enshrouded temples nestled in mountainous...

Google’s Eco-Friendly Routing Comes to Europe

Google expanded its eco-friendly routing on its Google Maps to 40 countries across Europe. With Google Map’s eco-friendly routing, drivers can choose a route that’s...

UK Pension Schemes Under Pressure for Climate Impact Reporting

The mid-sized and smaller pension schemes in the UK are under tighter rules as new reporting regulations are requiring more detailed information. The UK has...

Salesforce Launches First-of-a-Kind Carbon Credit Marketplace

The first step to achieving net zero is to reduce carbon emissions. In response to this, Salesforce will launch a first-of-its-kind carbon credit solution...

The 5 Top Carbon Offset Project Developers

Are you looking to directly reduce your carbon footprint or support projects that cut emissions elsewhere? Then carbon credits allow you to do either...

The Top 3 Private Carbon Companies to Watch Right Now

Right now, the carbon space is heating up. Dozens of companies are jumping into what’s fast becoming one of the hottest spaces to invest...

Carbon Insetting: The Target of Scope 3 Carbon Offset Accounting

Carbon offsets are a well-known sustainability concept so you most likely have heard of them. But there’s a relatively new sustainable supply chain term...

Tonne Year Accounting for Temporary Carbon Storage

You most likely know the climate benefits of storing carbon and removing gigatons of it from the atmosphere to limit climate change. But we also...